A Systematic Review Identifying Adverse Health Outcomes and Mortality Rates Associated with Telehealth
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30953/thmt.v8.415Keywords:
evidence-based practice, literature, PRISMA, telehealth, telemedicine, telecareAbstract
Background: The literature supporting telehealth management is growing accelerated by the COVID-pandemic. We hypothesize that there are risks of adverse events associated with telehealth interventions.
Methods: A review of PubMed (including MEDLINE), Embase, ISI (Web of Science), VHL/GHL, Scopus, Science Direct, and PsycINFO was conducted for all adverse events associated with telehealth from January 1, 1960 to March 1, 2021. This systematic review and meta-analyses were conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.
Results: Of 5,144 citations 78 published studies met criteria for quality evaluation and underwent full text abstraction including the qualitative synthesis. Of the 78 included studies 8 were included in the quantitative synthesis resulting in 2 meta-analyses. The results of the meta-analysis suggest that monitoring patients using telehealth techniques is associated with 40% lower mortality risks among patients suffering from heart failure, compared to those who received traditional care. The results of the random-effects meta-analysis showed the pooled relative risk of mortality to be 0.60, indicating that patients that underwent telemonitoring had a lower mortality risk compared with the patients that underwent usual care. Among patients with heart implants, patients who received telemonitoring had a 35% lower mortality risk compared to patients receiving traditional care.
Conclusions: While RCTs of telehealth interventions demonstrate enhanced patient outcomes in a number of studies and pave the way to evidence-based practice, the heterogeneity of the research questions suggest an important need for more complementary studies with consistent outcome assessments.
Downloads
References
Wherton J, Shaw S, Papoutsi C, Seuren L, Greenhalgh T. Guidance on the introduction and use of video consultations during COVID-19: important lessons from qualitative research. BMJ Leader. 2020:leader-2020-000262.
Catalyst N. What is telehealth? NEJM Catalyst. 2018;4(1).
Salisbury C, O'Cathain A, Edwards L, Thomas C, Gaunt D, Hollinghurst S, et al. Effectiveness of an integrated telehealth service for patients with depression: a pragmatic randomised controlled trial of a complex intervention. The Lancet Psychiatry. 2016;3(6):515-25.
Schutte-Rodin S. Telehealth, telemedicine, and obstructive sleep apnea. Sleep Medicine Clinics. 2020;15(3):359-75.
Wong MYZ, Gunasekeran DV, Nusinovici S, Sabanayagam C, Yeo KK, Cheng C-Y, et al. Telehealth demand trends during the COVID-19 pandemic in the top 50 most affected countries: Infodemiological evaluation. JMIR public health and surveillance. 2021;7(2):e24445.
Perle JG, Nierenberg B. How psychological telehealth can alleviate society's mental health burden: A literature review. Journal of Technology in Human Services. 2013;31(1):22-41.
Hanjani LS, Caffery LJ, Freeman CR, Peeters G, Peel NM. A scoping review of the use and impact of telehealth medication reviews. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy. 2020;16(8):1140-53.
Agboola S, Kvedar J, Target S. Telemedicine and Patient Safety: AHRQ Patient Safety Network. 2016.
Koehler F, Winkler S, Schieber M, Sechtem U, Stangl K, Böhm M, et al. Telemedical Interventional Monitoring in Heart Failure (TIM-HF), a randomized, controlled intervention trial investigating the impact of telemedicine on mortality in ambulatory patients with heart failure: study design. Eur J Heart Fail. 2010;12(12):1354-62.
Balduzzi S, Rücker G, Schwarzer G. How to perform a meta-analysis with R: a practical tutorial. Evidence-based mental health. 2019;22(4):153-60.
Altman DG, Bryant TN, Machin D, Gardner MJ. Statistics with confidence: confidence intervals and statistical guidelines: British Medical Journal; 2000.
McGuinness L, Higgins J. Risk-of-bias VISualization (robvis): An R package and Shiny web app for visualizing riskof-bias assessments. Research Synthesis Methods. 2020; 1-7.
Dendale P, De Keulenaer G, Troisfontaines P, Weytjens C, Mullens W, Elegeert I, et al. Effect of a telemonitoring‐facilitated collaboration between general practitioner and heart failure clinic on mortality and rehospitalization rates in severe heart failure: the TEMA‐HF 1 (TElemonitoring in the MAnagement of Heart Failure) study. European journal of heart failure. 2012;14(3):333-40.
Koehler F, Winkler S, Schieber M, Sechtem U, Stangl K, Böhm M, et al. Telemedical Interventional Monitoring in Heart Failure Investigators Impact of remote telemedical management on mortality and hospitalizations in ambulatory patients with chronic heart failure: the telemedical interventional monitoring in heart failure study. Circulation. 2011;123(17):1873-80.
Goldberg LR, Piette JD, Walsh MN, Frank TA, Jaski BE, Smith AL, et al. Randomized trial of a daily electronic home monitoring system in patients with advanced heart failure: the Weight Monitoring in Heart Failure (WHARF) trial. American heart journal. 2003;146(4):705-12.
Frederix I, Vanderlinden L, Verboven A-S, Welten M, Wouters D, De Keulenaer G, et al. Long-term impact of a six-month telemedical care programme on mortality, heart failure readmissions and healthcare costs in patients with chronic heart failure. Journal of telemedicine and telecare. 2019;25(5):286-93.
Villani A, Malfatto G, Compare A, Rosa FD, Bellardita L, Branzi G, et al. Clinical and psychological telemonitoring and telecare of high risk heart failure patients. Journal of telemedicine and telecare. 2014;20(8):468-75.
Hindricks G, Taborsky M, Glikson M, Heinrich U, Schumacher B, Katz A, et al. Implant-based multiparameter telemonitoring of patients with heart failure (IN-TIME): a randomised controlled trial. The Lancet. 2014;384(9943):583-90.
McKinstry B, Hanley J, Wild S, Pagliari C, Paterson M, Lewis S, et al. Telemonitoring based service redesign for the management of uncontrolled hypertension: multicentre randomised controlled trial. Bmj. 2013;346.
Green BB, Cook AJ, Ralston JD, Fishman PA, Catz SL, Carlson J, et al. Effectiveness of home blood pressure monitoring, Web communication, and pharmacist care on hypertension control: a randomized controlled trial. Jama. 2008;299(24):2857-67.
Lee TC, Kaiser TE, Alloway R, Woodle ES, Edwards MJ, Shah SA. Telemedicine based remote home monitoring after liver transplantation: results of a randomized prospective trial. Annals of surgery. 2019;270(3):564-72.
Nicolucci A, Cercone S, Chiriatti A, Muscas F, Gensini G, Group RS. A randomized trial on home telemonitoring for the management of metabolic and cardiovascular risk in patients with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes technology & therapeutics. 2015;17(8):563-70.
Maiolo C, Mohamed EI, Fiorani CM, De Lorenzo A. Home telemonitoring for patients with severe respiratory illness: the Italian experience. Journal of telemedicine and telecare. 2003;9(2):67-71.
Piotrowicz E, Pencina MJ, Opolski G, Zaręba W, Banach M, Kowalik I, et al. Effects of a 9-week hybrid comprehensive telerehabilitation program on long-term outcomes in patients with heart failure: the Telerehabilitation in Heart Failure Patients (TELEREH-HF) randomized clinical trial. JAMA cardiology. 2020;5(3):300-8.
Skobel E, Knackstedt C, Martinez-Romero A, Salvi D, Vera-Munoz C, Napp A, et al. Internet-based training of coronary artery patients: the Heart Cycle Trial. Heart and vessels. 2017;32(4):408-18.
Batalik L, Dosbaba F, Hartman M, Batalikova K, Spinar J. Benefits and effectiveness of using a wrist heart rate monitor as a telerehabilitation device in cardiac patients: A randomized controlled trial. Medicine. 2020;99(11).
Steventon A, Bardsley M, Billings J, Dixon J, Doll H, Hirani S, et al. Effect of telehealth on use of secondary care and mortality: findings from the Whole System Demonstrator cluster randomised trial. Bmj. 2012;344.
Egede LE, Acierno R, Knapp RG, Lejuez C, Hernandez-Tejada M, Payne EH, et al. Psychotherapy for depression in older veterans via telemedicine: a randomised, open-label, non-inferiority trial. The Lancet Psychiatry. 2015;2(8):693-701.
Reiss K, Andersen K, Pearson E, Biswas K, Taleb F, Ngo TD, et al. Unintended consequences of mHealth interactive voice messages promoting contraceptive use after menstrual regulation in Bangladesh: intimate partner violence results from a randomized controlled trial. Global Health: Science and Practice. 2019;7(3):386-403.
Smith C, Ngo TD, Gold J, Edwards P, Vannak U, Sokhey L, et al. Effect of a mobile phone-based intervention on post-abortion contraception: a randomized controlled trial in Cambodia. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2015;93:842-50A.
Ekeland AG, Bowes A, Flottorp S. Effectiveness of telemedicine: a systematic review of reviews. International journal of medical informatics. 2010;79(11):736-71.
Eze ND, Mateus C, Cravo Oliveira Hashiguchi T. Telemedicine in the OECD: an umbrella review of clinical and cost-effectiveness, patient experience and implementation. PLoS One. 2020;15(8):e0237585.
Snoswell CL, Chelberg G, De Guzman KR, Haydon HH, Thomas EE, Caffery LJ, et al. The clinical effectiveness of telehealth: a systematic review of meta-analyses from 2010 to 2019. Journal of telemedicine and telecare. 2021:1357633X211022907.
Snoswell CL, Stringer H, Taylor ML, Caffery LJ, Smith AC. An overview of the effect of telehealth on mortality: A systematic review of meta-analyses. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare. 2021:1357633X211023700.
Kalankesh LR, Pourasghar F, Nicholson L, Ahmadi S, Hosseini M. Effect of telehealth interventions on hospitalization indicators: A systematic review. Perspectives in health information management. 2016;13(Fall).
Marcolino MS, Maia LM, Oliveira JAQ, Melo LDR, Pereira BLD, Andrade-Junior DF, et al. Impact of telemedicine interventions on mortality in patients with acute myocardial infarction: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Heart. 2019;105(19):1479-86.
Snoswell CL, Taylor ML, Comans TA, Smith AC, Gray LC, Caffery LJ. Determining if telehealth can reduce health system costs: scoping review. Journal of medical Internet research. 2020;22(10):e17298.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Fidelia Cascini, MD, Ana Pantovic, MSc, Yazan A. Al-Ajlouni, MPhil, Omar Al-Ta’ani, MD, Giovanna Failla, MD, Andriy Melnyk, Paul Barach, BSC, MD, MPH, Maj, Walter Ricciardi, MD, MPH, MSc
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright of their work, with first publication rights granted to Telehealth and Medicine Today (THMT).
THMT is published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
